mixin it up
Mar. 15th, 2021 05:46 pm![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png)
Sorry this is so long and uncut, but that's what she said, and also every time I use cut tags on DW I run the risk of destroying all my formatting and I'm not in the mood for that type of danger.
FIRST: THE PARAMETERS
I DID feel qualified for bangers to be gay or get divorced to. In fact, I have essentially made two previous divorce mixes--one about the dissolution of a very close friendship, and one for a friend who literally had gotten divorced. Those were both a long time ago, nobody in the exchange has heard them, and the track lists are now lost to me, but still I had no desire to repeat myself, so knew I would have to go for a different vibe. It didn't really occur to me to focus on #7, but I kind of used it as a taste guide.
The other thing I used to judge Catie's taste was what I could find on her public spotify profile. She had a playlist called "divorce bops" which I did not realize was her own in-progress playlist for someone else in this same exchange, but I did visit it to get an idea of what artists she actually listens to.
SECOND: LE PROCÉSS
So like the FIRST thing I did was get distracted by another prompt in the exchange, "women experiencing insane emotions about other women or a rock or something" and spend a bunch of time trying to make a treat playlist for that instead of my assignment because i have ADHD, dammit. It occurs to me now that a fair amount of that vibe, perhaps especially the "or a rock or something," ended up bleeding into my actual assigned mix, but this was not on purpose. Thoughtful chin rub.
Once I remembered what I was supposed to be doing, and also acknowledged that my insane emotions playlist was not really coalescing, I just started throwing what was speaking to me on either prompts #1 or #2, sort of intending to build a comedy of remarriage narrative arc--gay love, gay breakup, gay get back together. Here I will acknowledge i was thinking a lot about my beloved ship Marceline the Vampire Queen/Princess Bubblegum, who canonically have this arc. I feel like I have spent my entire adult life agitating for Marceline to sing Kate Bush's "Hounds of Love" to Bubblegum, which she continues not to do (although the song she does sing to PB in Adventure Time Distant Lands: Obsidian has some validatingly similar themes) -- but at least I could put "Hounds of Love" on my mix.
Another song that jumped out at me early on was "Cosmonauts" by Fiona Apple, who has always blown me away with her lyrics and, on Fetch the Bolt Cutters, plays extensively with beats. What I find really interesting about this song is how ambivalent it is about love--I had been doing a deep dive into the lyrics of FTBC shortly before making this, and read some great quotes from her about how she doesn't know if she really wants eternal love--and that made it very compelling for my concept.
In fact, both "Hounds of Love" (I'm ashamed of running away from nothing real / I just can't deal with this, I'm still afraid to be there) and "Cosmonauts" (what I've become is something I can't be without your loving / be good to me, it isn't a game) have lyrics that touch on the terrifying transformative power of love, how vulnerable it makes them, how it maybe even changes who they are in a really fundamental sense. Combined with another early gimme, Björk's "5 Years," which is really narrated from the other side of this fear (I dare you to take me on ... I'm so bored with cowards that say they want, then they can't handle / you can't handle love) I had definitely hit on something.
I don't know exactly how I got from there to "Bad Believer" by St. Vincent (another artist I can rely on for interesting lyrics and beats) but it stuck with me as I was reviewing her ~oeuvre while looking for the right track. [Sidebar: one reason this challenge was so fun is because it made me listen to a lot of music, including stuff by artists I love that I thought had the right vibe, but I couldn't easily identify the exact right song and who maybe had dropped albums while I was not listening to much music and I needed to play catchup. St. Vincent's self-titled album was one of many that did not get enough attention from me at the time of its release.] I felt like it really fulfilled the "repetitive backbeat, interesting lyrics" request from Catie and I love how joyful and irreverent it is about something that's supposed to be serious. It just feels like it could be about any sort of article of faith, not just religious: the belief in love itself, belief in another person, or belief in a relationship, for that matter. What if I said we are never ever ever getting back together, but we do? What if we swore vows before god and everyone, but now we're breaking them? Oh well! What do you know, I'm just a bad believer! For reasons I cannot articulate any more clearly than this, this song somehow became foundational to the mix.
"Bad Believer" becoming a keystone of seemed to unlock the weirdness within, inviting both high-BPM pop and more off-the-wall indie artists like My Brightest Diamond and Thao and the Get Down Stay Down (both of whom had released stuff while I'd not been paying attention which ultimately yielded my selections). These two also go together because neither of the songs I chose from them are really either love or breakup songs at all. "Pressure" is about ... geological processes? and "Phenom" seems to be about a societal reckoning. What they have in common is what feels like deep time, ancient and primordial energies being harnessed for one's own ecstatic ascendance. I GUESS this ties in, for me, to the "be gay" prompt ... not homosexual as in happy, but queer as in fuck you I'm an unknowable force of the cosmos. ???? (What IS the transformative power of love transforming me into?) ("Cosmonauts": you commemorate the penetration of the sun into the deep dark sky) ?!
IDK.
Besides Marcy & PB, I kept thinking about ye olde Beatrice & Benedick as exes (maybe) who get back together, so even though my narrative arc became nonsense and I just started vibing with it rather than trying to tell a linear story, I used a quote from them to title the playlist. At first it was going to be "double heart," but I ended up going with "a jade's trick" and then adding "I know you of old" because ohhahhah there's a double meaning in that ahhhaha hah fdh ?FS sdfkjchjkdc. Etc.
THIRD: THE MIX!
In which I attempted to sum up within one 300x300 square image what the hell I had wrought:

a jade's trick (i know you of old)
tracklist, and a little more commentary
1. My Brightest Diamond - Pressure
- I hadn't thought about or listened to MBD for ages but was actually reminded of Shara's incredible voice quite recently when I started listening to Hayley Williams.
2. Hayley Williams - Dead Horse
- I never got into Paramore, but I stumbled on this solo album of hers recently and was digging it, and felt it would go well with Catie's citation of Metric (also felt it would be too obvious to actually include Metric) (???). The vibe is VERY "bangers to get divorced to."
3. Thao & the Get Down Stay Down - Phenom
- The Thao track that I should have used, narratively, is "Marrow," but energetically it was wrong.
- The Thao track I almost used instead was "Meticulous Bird," which even more than Phenom is interesting lyrics over a repetitive backbeat, but it is.... too much about sexual assault. Sorry thank you Thao!
4. Fiona Apple - Cosmonauts
5. Janelle Monáe - Pynk (feat. Grimes) (lol)
- no song is gayer. Thank you Janelle!
6. Mitski - Pink in the Night
- Pynk to Pink not why I did this transition, but very pleasing.
- "I've been blossoming alone over you" = ~transformative power of looooove~
7. Björk - 5 Years
- the song on the mix I've known the longest, by a wide margin. Homogenic has been one of my favorite albums of all time since I first bought it when I was getting into Björk as a youth.
- came really close to putting "Pluto" on instead for the queer dance party of it all but ultimately decided in favor of lyrical relevance. Plus I put "Pluto" on a mixtape I made for a guy in 2004 (i'm bISEXual) so I'm apparently not allowed to use it again. (???)
8. Kate Bush - Hounds of Love
- there's a really good cover by a Scandinavian artist called Eivør that I thought about putting on because this is sort of a different sound than the rest of the mix, but on the other hand, Kate Bush rules, so
9. Talking Heads - Right Start (unfinished outtake)
- I did not intend to make this an all-female-vocals mix, but then I accidentally built it that way and it would have been weird to have any male vocals, plus Talking Heads lyrics are so very... Talking Heads lyrics. But "Remain in Light" is one of my favorite albums and it has such good beats, and then I remembered that the Spotify/deluxe version, unlike the album version I grew up listening to that my dad played all the time, has instrumental outtakes at the end. This was just the vibe I wanted and felt like a nice turning point for the mix.
- To me, this doesn't really sound like any canonical Talking Heads song I know, BUT if you listen to it first and then to "Once in a Lifetime" you can hear how they used some of this for that song - the guitar hook appears faintly under the chorus.
10. Yeah Yeah Yeahs - Mysteries
- NEEDED a Karen O jam but could not figure it out until the last minute. When I figured it out it felt so obvious since the vibe is both "ambiguous love" and "unspeakable mysteries that are fun but also can get fucked."
11. Carly Rae Jepsen - For Sure

12. Robyn - Ever Again
- Honey is another album by a beloved artist that I hadn't listened to enough! But this was perfect. Robyn is perfect. I hope Catie enjoyed this brief break for more mainstream pop because I DID!!!!
13. Emily King - Can't Hold Me
- Huge, huge shoutout to nonbinary queen Rebecca Sugar for introducing me to this song, which is clearly about masturbation, by including it in Steven Universe Future and having intersex queen Stevonnie do an inspiring rollerskate dance to it!!!!!
14. St. Vincent - Bad Believer
TALK ABOUT NONBINARY QUEENS.